Contributory Negligence in NC: why comparative won't raise insurance rates
March 04, 2008
NC Lawyers' Weekly has provided a great link to an article that was run in the Winston-Salem Journal about contributory negligence laws in North Carolina.
Contrubutory Negligence is an issue that people don't know or care about, until they face the problem themselves. Basically, in NC, even if you are hurt by someone else's negligence, if the other person can prove you are just a little bit to blame for your injury, you are barred from any recovery. That's right. Someone else is 99.9% to blame, and you are barred from recovery.
Columnist Scott Sexton has written a series of excellent articles on the subject and really puts a human face on this convoluted and political issue. I highly recommend reading these articles.
I'll also add this to the mix. One of the problems with contributory negligence is that it is so often a bar to people seeking legal representation. Lawyers who represent injured people know that they could spend years working on case and lose everything at trial simply because a jury felt the Plaintiff may have played some very small part in causing the accident.
Here are some the the previous articles by Sexton:
Contibutory Negligence: it's "an insurance company's dream "
"Never mind that Joshua was 7 years old and was within 3 feet of the curb, or that Logan was drunk and driving on the wrong side of the road. "By way of affirmative defense, Defendant Logan pleads the contributory negligence of the decedent Plaintiff Joshua Franklin Palomares-Beckles," wrote Rodney Guthrie, Logan's attorney. If a jury in North Carolina decides that you are even a tiny bit at fault in this sort of case, you are entitled to nothing under state law, under a concept called contributory negligence. "In general, I'd say contributory negligence is an insurance company's dream," said Walter Holton Jr., the attorney who filed the lawsuit on behalf of Beckles-Palomares. "
Wreck victim faces being victimized by outdated law
"After an automobile accident in New Hanover County involving his daughter, Ashley, a student at the University of North Carolina at Wilmington, Norris has become something of an expert on a legal concept known as "contributory negligence," an outdated and completely unfair area of insurance law used only here and in three other states. That leaves option C. "Our insurance company is also using the contributory-negligence law claim that Ashley is limited in what we can recover," Norris said.
'There is no lobby for the little people' in this state
"Just four states - North Carolina, Virginia, Alabama and Maryland - still hang on to the concept of contributory negligence, a relic from English Common Law. "
 |
||
| Scott Sexton | ||
| Bio | ||
On its face, insurance law - specifically a legal concept called “contributory negligence” - is something that only a serious policy nerd could love.
That is, unless (or until) you or someone you know gets hosed by that law. Then it’s not so boring.
Contributory negligence works like this: If you’re in an accident and deemed to be just 1 percent at fault, you’re not legally entitled to one red cent to cover your damages from the idiot (or his or her insurance company) who was 99 percent to blame.
Three recent columns explored some of the more outrageous abuses of this law. Possibly the worst was the insurance-company attorney who argued that a 27-year-old man killed by a hit-and-run driver in October 2003 while changing a flat tire in Orange County was partly responsible for his own death.
It’s a shameless, outdated blame-the-victim strategy. It also seems like an easy law to change.
Yet objections remain. The state, for example, could switch to a “comparative-negligence” system. If you’re 90 percent at fault, you (or your insurance company) pay 90 percent of the damages.
“Comparative negligence is a nightmare to apply. Few people agree on the percent fault they are assessed, it increases lawsuits, is a cash cow for lawyers, and raises everyone’s insurance rates,” wrote one reader who works in the insurance industry. “If you haven’t noticed, N.C. enjoys some of the lowest auto-insurance rates in the country.”
Good point. And it’s one worth exploring.
Low-rate state
North Carolina does indeed enjoy consumer-friendly auto-insurance rates - the sixth lowest in the country, according to the N.C. Department of Insurance.
That’s not, however, because of any sense of fair play by insurance companies nor because contributory negligence keeps costs down.
The credit goes to a man who next to nobody has heard of, state Insurance Commissioner Jim Long. He is basically the final word on insurance rates in North Carolina.
Every Feb. 1, the N.C. Rate Bureau - an umbrella organization representing insurance companies - files a rate request. The bureau then makes a rate recommendation. Actuaries and attorneys with the Department of Insurance negotiate any changes with the rate bureau. If there’s no agreement, then Long decides.
“It’s a pretty long and pretty dull process unless you are an actuary,” said Chrissy Pearson, a spokeswoman for the Department of Insurance.
Given that background, I figured that Long’s thoughts on the merits of contributory negligence versus comparative merits would be worth hearing.
You can read the rest of the article by going to the Winston-Salem Journal.
-Chris Nichols
My family has recently run into this and it is quite scary to think that in our state of N.C. you better hope and pray nothing ever happens to you. How can this law still be on the books? My father is up against a huge company because he was injured on the job and it is documented in paper work that the company accepted fault for his injury, however from mediation we have learned that the "company" is pulling this law up on him despite the documentation that "they" are at fault. My father will most likely be left a feeble, wounded, unemployable man, that is guilty perhaps under this "contributory negligence" law because he SIMPLY showed up at work one day. People in N.C. and the other 3 states that still honor this law need to understand that YOU have NO RIGHTS if injured! What can we do to make this known to everyone before they become a victim? This is probably the most absurd law on the books because it removes your rights against individuals and or companies that cause injury or worse. This is a free ticket for mistreatment to the innocent.
Posted by: Amanda | August 25, 2008 at 08:16 PM
It's a good law. If you want continuous law suits because some idiot wants to walk in the street infront of your car. Sue you for everthing you have because you even own something, get rid of this law. I say it keeps people liable/responsible for thier own actions.
Posted by: Dan | October 16, 2008 at 09:57 AM
My 27 year old daughter was driving a car registered to me on 10-24-08 in Charlotte. She was in the center turning lane and a car to her right, crossed to lanes of traffic to make a left turn and my vehicle hit him. The police report said my daughter was "improperly using" the turning lane so the other insurance company decided my daughter contributed 10% to the accident and they have no responsibility to us. The same goes for my insurance carrier too, the other driver was 90% at fault but gets no protection from my insurance. You're right, this is an insurance company's dream.
We're just thankful no one was seriously injured or killed. My 4 year old grandaughter was in the back seat.
The real kicker is that I am responsible for the towing and storage fees on my totaled vehicle. Oh yeah, the medical bills for a trip to the emergency room are going to be arriving soon.
Posted by: Skeet Long | November 01, 2008 at 07:28 AM
Nice article,and useful also.
-------------
kate
Great Auto Insurance
Posted by: KATE | March 17, 2009 at 05:48 AM
As to the above posted 11/01/08 comment by Skeet Long, we are in almost the exact same situation. Does it make any sense to try and take a situation like this to court on my own without and law or insurance experience? or is it going to be a waste of time?
Posted by: Simon | October 24, 2009 at 11:23 AM
My family had to deal with law last year. My brother was chased by a pitt bull out into the road and got hit by a car. My daddy went out into the road to help my brother. Quite a few cars pulled over to assist my daddy. While they were tending to my brother another car started to approach. My daddy and several other people started waving the car down. The car never stopped. It hit my daddy and continue and hit my brother again. The car finally stopped, but it was to late. My daddy and brother died. Of course we went after the second driver. Thought we had a good case. Not in NC. They said my Daddy was at fault for his own death because he did not move out of the road when he seen the other car comming. It was also a Saturday, and evidentally my daddy had drink a few beers. He was not drunk, but because of those two factors he contribute to his death. I do not think that any parent would of just moved and let a car run over thier child. I guess the insuranace companies dont care about what is right.
Posted by: Betty Oliver | January 13, 2010 at 04:45 PM
You say that..... but wait till it happens to you!
Posted by: Renee | January 13, 2010 at 11:23 PM
Dear Betty Oliver,
Rest assured that GOD knows and sees what these insurance co. are doing and they will not get away with what they are doing they think so but they aren't. Be incouraged that GOD knows what you are going through.
Posted by: Renee | January 13, 2010 at 11:33 PM
I myself have the same problem with a insurance co. they say i contributed 1% to the accident so that makes me negligence by nc law .
Posted by: Wilbert wiggins | January 14, 2010 at 08:18 AM
My husband just got hit August 10,2010
He was riding his bicycle trying to cross over fast before car came
They said it was his fault state trooper took the driver side instead of my husband side ,he can't take up for his self because he is fighting for his life in ICU and I think this law needs to get rid of the law .
because insurance companies getting away with murder .we all need to do something about it .
Kimberly Dixon
Posted by: Kimberly Dixon | August 14, 2010 at 03:36 PM
This might be your absolute best option if you: Don't possess the occasion or desire for a medical exam Need life insurance swiftly to secure a loan on your business Don't have any serious health conditions Need $499,000 orr less in protection Are seeking a quick and cost-effective solution to make sure your family potential life insurance with nno examination If you're between your ages of 50 & 80, you can buy as much as $25,000. Forget about medical assessments or extended purposes to get the life insurance you want and need. We promise you won’t be turned down for LegacySM Life (not available in every states.) You immediately qualify if you’re involving the ages of 50 and 80! Utilize your earnings to cover your medical expenses, funeral fees and to offer additional satisfaction for you and your loved ones. You will get up-to $25,000 of insurance Prices won’t increase when you grow old That is permanent life insurance you are able to maintain your complete life Basic program - your acknowledgement is quaranteed Limited benefit for first two years (death benefit is limited to 110-volt of payments compensated in first 2 years) Simple existence insurance For insurance quantities below $100,000, we offer refined problem term life insurance, with no health-related quiz and same-day approval. You can purchase this coverage right on the telephone to-day. life insurance with no medical examination, http://lifeinsurancenoexam2.tumblr.com/, Level term life insurance For protection quantities $100,000+, we provide term life insurance plans with premiums guaranteed never to increase for the length of the term. Today you're able to implement bby phone or online for this coverage. Observee economical expression existence insurance can be-start here using an prompt quotation. (Q) How aged do I've to become to buy living insurance? (A) 18 years of age to apply (Q) Just how much insurance can I buy online? (A) You could purchase around $250,000 (Q) How can I receive my policy? (A) Your plan will be delivered to you by the insurance carrier (Q) Is there age restrictions? (A) Our guidelines can be found for anyone ages 18-64 (Q) Can I acquire living insurance online if I smoke? (A) Yes term life insurance no medical exam or health questions, lifeinsurancenoexam2.tumblr.com, (Q) Just how long does the applying method take? (A) Typically 15 minutes or less (Q) The length of time can it decide to try get my coverage? (A) Underwriting will change on an individual schedule (Q) Do I need to be in great health to purchase online? (A) No, but extra information could possibly be necessary to obtain insurance policy (Q) Will my value fluctuate as time passes? (A) No, charges can stay set through the level-term period of the plan (Q) What is an inheritor? (A) The person you determine to have the sum of payment provided in the event of one's death whole lifve insurance no medical exam no health questions (lifeinsurancenoexam2.tumblr.com) If you should be looking forr quick, easy, affordable Medical insurance rates, your search is over! With one easy click we could match you with Medical heakth insurance policies frokm recognized corporations. All you need to do is revieww charges and pick which company iis the bet foor you! We've plumped for top-tier associates with charges for sale in your area. Store and assess via our bodies, and find the organization and Medical health insurance policy that fits your requirements. Prepare for the future today with the comprehensive Medical insurance policy information you need. Finish our price container above, apply for your free insurance quotesand disappear with superior prices, it is possible to afford. Our bodies makes it simple.
Posted by: life insurance with no examination | November 07, 2013 at 12:50 AM
I used to be able to find good advice from your blog posts.
Posted by: CHeap Hostgator Hosting | November 08, 2013 at 02:34 AM
Why visitors still make use of to read news papers when in this technological globe everything is presented on net?
Posted by: nrl results | November 10, 2013 at 06:48 PM
Your style is really unique in comparison to other folks I've read stuff from. Thanks for posting when you've got the opportunity, Guess I will just book mark this site.
Posted by: do you agree | November 12, 2013 at 10:08 PM
Your style is so unique in comparison to other folks I've read stuff from. Thank you for posting when you've got the opportunity, Guess I will just bookmark this site.
Posted by: fatest way to burn belly fat | November 14, 2013 at 12:16 AM
This is really interesting, You're a very skilled blogger. I've joined your rss feed and look forward to seeking more of your wonderful post. Also, I have shared your website in my social networks!
Posted by: Ermelinda | November 14, 2013 at 07:52 AM
Hi there this is kinda of off topic but I was wondering if blogs use WYSIWYG editors or if you have to manually code with HTML. I'm starting a blog soon but have no coding skills so I wanted to get guidance from someone with experience. Any help would be greatly appreciated!
Posted by: Gudrun | November 14, 2013 at 08:52 AM
I don't know if it's just me or if perhaps everybody else encountering problems with your site. It appears like some of the written text in your posts are running off the screen. Can someone else please provide feedback and let me know if this is happening to them as well? This could be a issue with my browser because I've had this happen previously. Cheers
Posted by: appliance repair tampa | November 14, 2013 at 02:59 PM
Good day! Do you use Twitter? I'd like to follow you if that would be ok. I'm absolutely enjoying your blog and look forward to new updates.
Posted by: Alana | November 23, 2013 at 11:46 PM
Nice blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere? A theme like yours with a few simple tweeks would really make my blog stand out. Please let me know where you got your design. Kudos
Posted by: website | November 26, 2013 at 11:42 AM
Aw, this was an extremely good post. Spending some time and actual effort to create a really good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate a lot and never manage to get nearly anything done.
Posted by: Dann | November 30, 2013 at 06:20 AM
Films x gratuits amateur streaming à visionner en streaming amateur streaming amateur streaming
Posted by: amateur streaming | January 10, 2014 at 07:38 AM